Dangerous Girls by Abigail Haas
My rating: 5 of 5 teacups
“Wouldn’t we all look guilty, if someone searched hard enough?”
Why, hello there, awesome book. You managed to take me straight out of this whole Goodreads censorship/deleting reviews fiasco and plant me right inside another time and place; many brave books have tried and failed this past week to do what you have done. So, thank you.
Dangerous Girls is in danger. It’s in danger of being underread. It’s in danger of being given a quick once over and then dismissed as something vapid, senseless and probably crap. It isn’t, my friends. It’s damn good. Dangerous Girls is one of those multi-layered books that does several different things at once and still manages to do each one equally well. Haas does what, in my opinion, all good mystery writers should do: she doesn’t hang everything precariously-balanced on her reveals. The ending is fantastic but it doesn’t matter because the book is also about so many other things. It is a satisfying story from start to finish that took me through so many different emotions.
So, what is this book? It’s a mature YA mystery. I use “YA” with some hesitation here because it’s full of all the kinda stuff that will make some parents clutch their rosary beads – sex, alcohol abuse, drug use… oh yeah, and there’s that whole murder thing too. It’s about a teen summer vacation gone wrong. Anna, her best friend – Elise, her boyfriend – Tate, as well as others, all go to party hard, get laid and have fun. Then, one day, Elise is discovered stabbed to death in her bed and Anna and Tate are the prime suspects. From there, we are taken on a journey through a murder trial that seems to paint Anna in a worse light with every piece of “evidence” provided. The story of the present is also broken up with flashbacks into how Anna and Elise became friends.
This is a dark story that takes you through the many nasty corners of teen girl friendships but it also shows the other side, the importance of friends to one another and the complicated psychology behind it all. Elise is such a wonderfully complex character. I think most people know an Elise. That reckless, volatile person who is always the life of the party, so confident, often overtly sexual and looking for a new adventure at every turn. But underneath there’s something a bit different, a sadness or an anger or loneliness, that hides beneath the mask they’ve created.
My knowledge of the law and judicial system is limited to one year at AS that I hated, so I’m far from an expert on what is realistic or not. But I’ve always been fascinated by the portrayal of court trials as a kind of show or circus where everyone plays their parts. Where it isn’t about guilty/not guilty, but about the performance you put on and how convincingly you deliver the script. Like in the musical, Chicago. Anna’s trial resembles a circus and it horrifies me at the way each little piece of a person’s life can be taken out of context and manipulated to mean whatever the prosecutor chooses. Scary.
I honestly loved everything about this wild little gem and I’m now going to recommend it to everyone I know. That means YOU too.